Re: [arch-dev-public] gcc-4.4.0 toolchain rebuild with query about gcc-gcj and related packages
On Sat, 2009-05-02 at 03:17 +1000, Allan McRae wrote:
So, looking into this further, apart from java-gcj-compat and eclipse-ecj, we have two packages that depend on gcc-gcj (gjdoc and jikes) and two that makedepend on java-gcj-compat (bcprov, juint - can probably be changed to openjdk6), but nothing else for eclipse-ecj. The apache-ant and openjdk6 PKGBUILDs both mention java-gcj-compat in a trivial way.
So packages that would also need looked at to be removed when gcc-gcj, java-gcj-compat and eclipse-ecj go, are gjdoc and jikes. Jikes is a orphan and dead upstream as far as I can tell. It is also not needed given javac that comes with openjdk6. gjdoc is currently only a dep for java-gcj-compat.
The only issue with packages in [community] is that classpath depends in jikes.
The makedepends on gcj or java-gcj-compat can be changed to openjdk6. As for classpath in community: classpath is an abandoned project and was merged into gcj, which was abandoned when Sun released OpenJDK as GPL. I don't think we should care so much about it. About eclipse-ecj: it's outdated because of the gcj patch, newer versions don't work with gcj. We could keep it and build with openjdk if we want, as eclipse-ecj is a faster compiler than javac itself in some situations (mainly when used as JSP compiler for Tomcat or any other servlet container).
Jan de Groot wrote:
On Sat, 2009-05-02 at 03:17 +1000, Allan McRae wrote:
So, looking into this further, apart from java-gcj-compat and eclipse-ecj, we have two packages that depend on gcc-gcj (gjdoc and jikes) and two that makedepend on java-gcj-compat (bcprov, juint - can probably be changed to openjdk6), but nothing else for eclipse-ecj. The apache-ant and openjdk6 PKGBUILDs both mention java-gcj-compat in a trivial way.
So packages that would also need looked at to be removed when gcc-gcj, java-gcj-compat and eclipse-ecj go, are gjdoc and jikes. Jikes is a orphan and dead upstream as far as I can tell. It is also not needed given javac that comes with openjdk6. gjdoc is currently only a dep for java-gcj-compat.
The only issue with packages in [community] is that classpath depends in jikes.
The makedepends on gcj or java-gcj-compat can be changed to openjdk6. As for classpath in community: classpath is an abandoned project and was merged into gcj, which was abandoned when Sun released OpenJDK as GPL. I don't think we should care so much about it. About eclipse-ecj: it's outdated because of the gcj patch, newer versions don't work with gcj. We could keep it and build with openjdk if we want, as eclipse-ecj is a faster compiler than javac itself in some situations (mainly when used as JSP compiler for Tomcat or any other servlet container).
I'm happy for for eclipse-ecj to stay around in that format. Do you (or someone else) want to make this change and maintain the package? My motivation towards it is minimal... I would like to move the toolchain around Thursday so I can start with the new glibc release on Friday so this would need addressed by then. Allan
participants (2)
-
Allan McRae
-
Jan de Groot