On 02/23/2012 12:48 AM, Alfredo Palhares wrote:
Hello Don,
Excerpts from Don deJuan's message of Thu Feb 23 07:35:52 +0100 2012:
What is considered the Arch way to have version control over the configs in /etc? I would like to be able to see at least a few changes back in my config history at the minimum.
I too keep my /etc directory under version control. I have a a detached worktree. Wich enables me to have the .git directory outside of /etc. The process is simple:
You create a bare repo: $ mkdir etc.git $ git init --bare Now lets congigure it to chek the files elsewhere: $ git config core.worktree /etc And export these vars to you current session $ export GIT_DIR=/path/to/etc.git $ export GIT_WORK_TREE=/etc
Tip here a script[1] easy to work it. Just rember to run it with "." or "source" *not* with "sh" since it open another bash session and kills it when script is done.
Now you would be able to git add and git commit in your etc while keeping it clean. :)
I have seen the package etckeeper and it does not seem to really fully be setup to work with pacman. Both AUR packages are very outdated. etckeeper doesn't really fit pacman cause pacman doesn't merge files automatically, only apt does that (if you silly enough to configure it to do that :p ). Also etckeeper commits all the files in /etc wich makes quite dummy commits. They not really resetable... I use use it on debian server only as the last resource.
The Arch way is quite simpler, every time you merge a pacnew or add a feature to a config file you commit it and keep the same workflow as a normal code repo. Much simpler.
Would I just be best off just copying the ones I change and then push the changes to a separate dir that is under control of say git? What methods do you employ? Well this is kinda hard to do (believe me i tried) Also having the .git on /etc and other dirs like $HOME is quite anoying since i get the (branch) in red on my bash prompt[2].
I hope this can help you.
[1] https://github.com/masterkorp/Home-files/blob/master/scripts/export_git.sh [2] https://github.com/masterkorp/Home-files/blob/master/.bashrc
What about permissions and ownership? These are pretty important for /etc.