Hi all,
AUR has the package celt which I've always had installed (installed it long time back to compile some audio app). http://aur.archlinux.org/packages.php?ID=27117
Repos have celt-0.7 which provides celt.
Thing is, when I try to makepkg jack-audio-connection-kit-mp (which doesn't depend on celt at all) it fails when celt is installed, but works when celt-0.7 or no celt is installed.
There's overlap between AUR packages and other stuff here, so I'm not sure whether this belongs on this ML, or even in a personal email to the maintainer. In which case, my question would be, which maintainer?
Thanks.
Excerpts from Ng Oon-Ee's message of 2010-07-28 04:13:04 +0200:
Hi all,
AUR has the package celt which I've always had installed (installed it long time back to compile some audio app). http://aur.archlinux.org/packages.php?ID=27117
Repos have celt-0.7 which provides celt.
Thing is, when I try to makepkg jack-audio-connection-kit-mp (which doesn't depend on celt at all) it fails when celt is installed, but works when celt-0.7 or no celt is installed.
There's overlap between AUR packages and other stuff here, so I'm not sure whether this belongs on this ML, or even in a personal email to the maintainer. In which case, my question would be, which maintainer?
Thanks.
You can try to explicitly disable celt support. Celt is only needed for netjack to work over the internet. It should be possible to build jack with netjack support but without celt, in which case it would only work in a LAN. If that is not possible, then this is actually a upstream bug.
Am Mittwoch 28 Juli 2010, 12:26:47 schrieb Philipp Überbacher:
Excerpts from Ng Oon-Ee's message of 2010-07-28 04:13:04 +0200:
Hi all,
AUR has the package celt which I've always had installed (installed it long time back to compile some audio app). http://aur.archlinux.org/packages.php?ID=27117
Repos have celt-0.7 which provides celt.
Thing is, when I try to makepkg jack-audio-connection-kit-mp (which doesn't depend on celt at all) it fails when celt is installed, but works when celt-0.7 or no celt is installed.
There's overlap between AUR packages and other stuff here, so I'm not sure whether this belongs on this ML, or even in a personal email to the maintainer. In which case, my question would be, which maintainer?
Thanks.
You can try to explicitly disable celt support. Celt is only needed for netjack to work over the internet. It should be possible to build jack with netjack support but without celt, in which case it would only work in a LAN. If that is not possible, then this is actually a upstream bug.
Hello,
i am the maintainer of jack-audio-connection-kit-mp. I noticed your message in the comments of my package and started reproducing this error. I will investigate this and reply soon here.
Thanks for your diagnostic!
On 28 July 2010 23:42, Thomas Bahn Thomas-Bahn@gmx.net wrote:
Am Mittwoch 28 Juli 2010, 12:26:47 schrieb Philipp Überbacher:
Excerpts from Ng Oon-Ee's message of 2010-07-28 04:13:04 +0200:
Hi all,
AUR has the package celt which I've always had installed (installed it long time back to compile some audio app). http://aur.archlinux.org/packages.php?ID=27117
Repos have celt-0.7 which provides celt.
Thing is, when I try to makepkg jack-audio-connection-kit-mp (which doesn't depend on celt at all) it fails when celt is installed, but works when celt-0.7 or no celt is installed.
There's overlap between AUR packages and other stuff here, so I'm not sure whether this belongs on this ML, or even in a personal email to the maintainer. In which case, my question would be, which maintainer?
Thanks.
You can try to explicitly disable celt support. Celt is only needed for netjack to work over the internet. It should be possible to build jack with netjack support but without celt, in which case it would only work in a LAN. If that is not possible, then this is actually a upstream bug.
Hello,
i am the maintainer of jack-audio-connection-kit-mp. I noticed your message in the comments of my package and started reproducing this error. I will investigate this and reply soon here.
CELT is used by jack{1,2} for audio relay over the internet, and it is _very_ experimental (API can change between minor revisions). If installed and waf detects a package "celt" on the system, regardless of the version, jackd will build with it. However, waf configure lists no option to disable celt, so it is an upstream problem.
jack2/jackmp depends on celt API version 0.5 OR 0.7, nothing lesser or greater. Even though it is a ">=" requirement, the build fails when 0.8 is installed, and so is an upstream issue once again. Version 0.8 is "NOT bit-stream compatible" with previous versions; applications need to rebase their code if a rebuild is not enough.
Solution: celt-0.7 or no celt
-- GPG/PGP ID: B42DDCAD
On Sat, 2010-07-31 at 04:27 +0800, Ray Rashif wrote:
On 28 July 2010 23:42, Thomas Bahn Thomas-Bahn@gmx.net wrote:
Hello,
i am the maintainer of jack-audio-connection-kit-mp. I noticed your message in the comments of my package and started reproducing this error. I will investigate this and reply soon here.
CELT is used by jack{1,2} for audio relay over the internet, and it is _very_ experimental (API can change between minor revisions). If installed and waf detects a package "celt" on the system, regardless of the version, jackd will build with it. However, waf configure lists no option to disable celt, so it is an upstream problem.
jack2/jackmp depends on celt API version 0.5 OR 0.7, nothing lesser or greater. Even though it is a ">=" requirement, the build fails when 0.8 is installed, and so is an upstream issue once again. Version 0.8 is "NOT bit-stream compatible" with previous versions; applications need to rebase their code if a rebuild is not enough.
Solution: celt-0.7 or no celt
Thanks Ray, so its just an upstream 'issue'. Perhaps the versioned deps for jack/jackdmp should be updated to indicate that, Thomas?
arch-general@lists.archlinux.org