[aur-general] Why are orphan requests accepted immediately although wiki says there's a 2 weeks wating period ?
Hi, Recently I received a notification message that a package I was co-maintainer from had changed ownership. I looked at aur-requests archive and saw the orphan request was filed on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021. The request was accepted on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021 or within a second ! I checked https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/AUR_submission_guidelines#Requests which states
Orphan requests will be granted after two weeks if the current maintainer did not react.
The immediate acceptance has made it impossible for the maintainer / co-maintainers to respond. Is the wiki incorrect wrt policy for orphan requests ? If so, where is the correct policy described ? Lone_Wolf
Unsubscrube On Sat, 2 Jan 2021, 15:46 Lone_Wolf via aur-general, < aur-general@lists.archlinux.org> wrote:
Hi,
Recently I received a notification message that a package I was co-maintainer from had changed ownership.
I looked at aur-requests archive and saw the orphan request was filed on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021.
The request was accepted on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021 or within a second !
I checked https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/AUR_submission_guidelines#Requests which states
Orphan requests will be granted after two weeks if the current maintainer did not react.
The immediate acceptance has made it impossible for the maintainer / co-maintainers to respond.
Is the wiki incorrect wrt policy for orphan requests ?
If so, where is the correct policy described ?
Lone_Wolf
On Sat, Jan 02, 2021 at 07:46:04PM +0100, Lone_Wolf via aur-general wrote:
Hi,
Recently I received a notification message that a package I was co-maintainer from had changed ownership.
I looked at aur-requests archive and saw the orphan request was filed on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021.
The request was accepted on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021 or within a second !
I checked https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/AUR_submission_guidelines#Requests which states
Orphan requests will be granted after two weeks if the current maintainer did not react.
The immediate acceptance has made it impossible for the maintainer / co-maintainers to respond.
Is the wiki incorrect wrt policy for orphan requests ?
If so, where is the correct policy described ?
Yo, The only exception is with packages that has been flagged out-of-date for months, which was the case here if this is about openrc.
The package base has been flagged out-of-date since 2019-07-27.
So with half a year with an OOD flag and no actions the orphan request gets automatically accepted. -- Morten Linderud PGP: 9C02FF419FECBE16
On 02-01-2021 19:51, Morten Linderud via aur-general wrote:
On Sat, Jan 02, 2021 at 07:46:04PM +0100, Lone_Wolf via aur-general wrote:
Hi,
Recently I received a notification message that a package I was co-maintainer from had changed ownership.
I looked at aur-requests archive and saw the orphan request was filed on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021.
The request was accepted on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021 or within a second !
I checked https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/AUR_submission_guidelines#Requests which states
Orphan requests will be granted after two weeks if the current maintainer did not react. The immediate acceptance has made it impossible for the maintainer / co-maintainers to respond.
Is the wiki incorrect wrt policy for orphan requests ?
If so, where is the correct policy described ? Yo,
The only exception is with packages that has been flagged out-of-date for months, which was the case here if this is about openrc.
The package base has been flagged out-of-date since 2019-07-27. So with half a year with an OOD flag and no actions the orphan request gets automatically accepted.
(yes, package was openrc) If that's the policy, then the immediate orphaning was correct. Could TUs add this exception to the wiki ? LW
On 02/01/2021 20:18, Lone_Wolf via aur-general wrote:
On 02-01-2021 19:51, Morten Linderud via aur-general wrote:
On Sat, Jan 02, 2021 at 07:46:04PM +0100, Lone_Wolf via aur-general wrote:
Hi,
Recently I received a notification message that a package I was co-maintainer from had changed ownership.
I looked at aur-requests archive and saw the orphan request was filed on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021.
The request was accepted on Sat Jan 2 09:42:38 UTC 2021 or within a second !
I checked https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/AUR_submission_guidelines#Requests which states
Orphan requests will be granted after two weeks if the current maintainer did not react. The immediate acceptance has made it impossible for the maintainer / co-maintainers to respond.
Is the wiki incorrect wrt policy for orphan requests ?
If so, where is the correct policy described ? Yo,
The only exception is with packages that has been flagged out-of-date for months, which was the case here if this is about openrc.
The package base has been flagged out-of-date since 2019-07-27. So with half a year with an OOD flag and no actions the orphan request gets automatically accepted.
(yes, package was openrc)
If that's the policy, then the immediate orphaning was correct.
Could TUs add this exception to the wiki ?
LW
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?title=AUR_submission_guidelines&diff=648050&oldid=646641 Alad
On 02-01-2021 20:40, alad via aur-general wrote:
On 02/01/2021 20:18, Lone_Wolf via aur-general wrote:
On 02-01-2021 19:51, Morten Linderud via aur-general wrote:
The only exception is with packages that has been flagged out-of-date for months, which was the case here if this is about openrc.
The package base has been flagged out-of-date since 2019-07-27. So with half a year with an OOD flag and no actions the orphan request gets automatically accepted.
(yes, package was openrc)
If that's the policy, then the immediate orphaning was correct.
Could TUs add this exception to the wiki ?
LW
https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php?title=AUR_submission_guidelines&diff=648050&oldid=646641
Alad
Thank you both for the quick responses and actions. LW
participants (4)
-
alad
-
Lone_Wolf
-
Martín Fixman
-
Morten Linderud