On Wed, Nov 27, 2013 at 05:20:43AM +0800, Rashif Ray Rahman wrote:

On 27 November 2013 04:43, Lieven Moors lievenmoors@gmail.com wrote:

...

I think technically, ntk-git should provide ntk, and non-daw-git should depend on some git-release of ntk.

You can depend on ntk-git, but a better approach is to have ntk-git provide ntk, and depend on that -- if devel functionality of ntk is not required by non-daw-git. So just nudge the ntk-git maintainer.

With devel functionality, do you mean header files? Wouldn't they be needed to build non-daw-git anyway?

The problem is that ntk-git has been in a state of constant flux, and non-daw-git would often refuse to build, unless you rebuild ntk-git first...

On Thu, Nov 28, 2013 at 02:41:42AM +0800, Rashif Ray Rahman wrote:

On 28 November 2013 02:27, Lieven Moors lievenmoors@gmail.com wrote:

...

With devel functionality, do you mean header files? Wouldn't they be needed to build non-daw-git anyway?

I meant experimental functionality (i.e. development branch).

...

The problem is that ntk-git has been in a state of constant flux, and non-daw-git would often refuse to build, unless you rebuild ntk-git first...

Then you should just depend on ntk (but doesn't make a difference if a git development source is all there is).

Yes, I think I'll keep depending on ntk. There might be a stable ntk in the near future, and then I'll see how non-daw-git behaves with that.

Thanks for your help,

lieven

On Tue, Nov 26, 2013 at 07:28:17PM -0200, Gabriel B. Casella wrote:

On Tue, Nov 26, 2013 at 6:43 PM, Lieven Moors lievenmoors@gmail.com wrote:

...

Hi,

I was wondering if it would be ok to let my package (non-daw-git) depend on the ntk-git package instead of ntk. The package ntk is not yet available in AUR, but ntk-git is. I think technically, ntk-git should provide ntk, and non-daw-git should depend on some git-release of ntk. The downside for the user is that helpers like yaourt won't find the dependency.

BTW, I just did a small test here and yaourt does find the ntk-git dependency through AUR.

Ah, I should have checked it myself again. I think the problem was that AUR doesn't allow you to search for provides through the web interface. And another problem was that when you rebuild non-daw-git, you forget that most of the time you have to rebuild ntk-git as well, and yaourt has no way of knowing that.

I already left a message for the ntk-git maintainer. If he would include the commit count in the version string, it should be possible to depend on a specific git "release". I guess that would be the best solution...

lieven