Hello,
there has been a thread on aur-general in October 2008 about this issue, but the situation is not satisfying IMHO: We have a package of empathe in AUR _and_ in [testing].Both are or were orphaned, and the package in AUR was taken by a user and upgraded to version 2.25. I was chatting with him, and we reverted the change and uploaded a release 2.25 as empathy-devel.
I think this should not happen again. What is the decision? Will empathe go to [extra] soon?
If it is desired to keep the version in AUR, I suggest a developer should take it and keep it until it reaches [extra]. Or it should be removed.
Thoughts?
Regards Stefan
On Wed, 2008-12-31 at 15:21 +0100, stefan-husmann@t-online.de wrote:
Hello,
there has been a thread on aur-general in October 2008 about this issue, but the situation is not satisfying IMHO: We have a package of empathe in AUR _and_ in [testing].Both are or were orphaned, and the package in AUR was taken by a user and upgraded to version 2.25. I was chatting with him, and we reverted the change and uploaded a release 2.25 as empathy-devel.
I think this should not happen again. What is the decision? Will empathe go to [extra] soon?
If it is desired to keep the version in AUR, I suggest a developer should take it and keep it until it reaches [extra]. Or it should be removed.
Thoughts?
Hello Stafan,
The reason why Empathy is still in testing and unmaintained is because I took it to testing when GNOME 2.24 was released. After GNOME moved to extra, I didn't move empathy because I'm not happy with the current state of the telepathy stack on archlinux. I don't have any interest in this package as I'm a happy pidgin user. If a TU wants to maintain empathy in community together with the telepathy stack that is required to use empathy, I'm happy to move it back.
Regards, Jan
On Wed, 2008-12-31 at 15:42 +0100, Jan de Groot wrote:
The reason why Empathy is still in testing and unmaintained is because I took it to testing when GNOME 2.24 was released. After GNOME moved to extra, I didn't move empathy because I'm not happy with the current state of the telepathy stack on archlinux. I don't have any interest in this package as I'm a happy pidgin user. If a TU wants to maintain empathy in community together with the telepathy stack that is required to use empathy, I'm happy to move it back.
That's kind of the problem.
I have been using telepathy together with Bjørn (former TU) for a long time, but even until now, it's not very useful.
Except for XMPP I have to use Pidgin for all other protocols, and empathy as a frontend still lacks the major features (administrative XMPP stuff for example), so I have to use even other clients for that (Gajim, Psi).
In the end, except for some nicer UI, Telepathy/Empathy is nowhere close to Pidgin or (if you only use one chat-service) special clients like Gajim for example.
So following "one program for one task" I would decide for Pidgin as the main GNOME chat program instead of Empathy (for now).
aur-general@lists.archlinux.org