To the moderators reviewing this orphan request:

Since the current maintainer has had to accept the reality of a fork being a fork, he has reverted the source repo back to the original. However, he has pinned his own comment on the package page falsely claiming that the package has been superseeded by neowaita-git, which directly contradicts NeoWaita's developer's own words. NeoWaita is a fork of MoreWaita, it's taking its own path, and does not replace or superseed MoreWaita.

I can see no other reason but spite for doing what the current maintainer is doing these past few days. He clearly dislikes me and my project, yet he insists on holding on to the AUR repo and using it against my project and myself. He has never done anything close to what's written in point 7 of the Arch Package Guidelines about closely working with upstream.

In light of all this, I request the moderators to orphan the morewaita-git package if That1Calculator doesn't do it himself, so I can pick it it up and maintain it properly for the community.

Thank you!

On Sat, 21 Sept 2024, 23:20 , <somepaulo@gmail.com> wrote:
The author of the new fork has confirmed he is going to rename it to
Neowaita or possibly something else, so there is no point in linking
this package to that repo as it will not take over the MoreWaita
project whether you like it or not. It is going it's own separate way.
Please refer to this issue on the GitHub repo that you've linked the
morewaita-git package to:
https://github.com/MoreWaita-Dev/MoreWaita/issues/1

You can quickly and easily create a new package for Neowaita or
whatever it will end up being named, but I would offer help to the
developers with doing that before jumping the gun. That's how both the
AUR packages were created. The prolific Dušan Simić stepped in and
offered great help. That's what people do in Open Source.

So, for the 7th(? I've lost count) time, please either revert the
source to the original MoreWaita repo at
https://github.com/somepaulo/MoreWaita or disown the morewaita-git
package if you don't want to maintain my project under its original
name. Thank you!

On Sat, Sep 21 2024 at 20:50:46 +01:00:00, Paulo Fino
<somepaulo@gmail.com> wrote:
> You said "facetious".
>
> Facetious
> adjective
>  treating serious issues with deliberately inappropriate humour;
> flippant.
>  "a facetious remark"
>  Oxford dictionary of English
>
> Not that I owe you any explanation of how and when I maintain my
> project, but here's a brief summary for the sake of whoever is
> reviewing this.
>
> I have not abandoned my project. I was going through life stuff for a
> while, but I've been developing again lately, and I'm preparing to
> release MoreWaita v47 in about 10 days with many new icons and a
> structural refactoring that may break stuff. It did for me locally.
> I've been developing offline not to spam the git tree with half-baked
> stuff. I've almost finished the refactoring and started working on
> icons including the pending requests hoping to commit them for those
> on the git version before the new release is ready, but now I can't
> even update my system install with the new commits without having to
> edit the hijacked PKGBUILD.
>
> The author of the fork you have linked this package to also assumed
> the project was dead, having waited "2-3 days" for an answer to an
> icon request. When I told him though, he said he was going to change
> the project name and continue on his own path. Here's a link to his
> own words if you haven't read my comment on the AUR:
> https://www.reddit.com/r/gnome/comments/1fkjsdq/comment/lo6knc0/
>
> Interesting how neither of you even thought of reaching out with a
> simple question. Not to mention an offer of co-maintenance or a
> takeover request. There are more criteria to deeming a project
> abandoned than just a few months of inactivity and a few ungranted
> requests, not bugs, mind you.
>
> So, effectively, you are hijacking this package by linking it to a
> fork while using the original name of a live project. There's nothing
> stopping you from creating a new package for the forked project using
> a different name like `morewaita-fork-git` or something entirely
> different. The point here being the fork is not MoreWaita.
>
> The `morewaita-git` package name belongs with the original project
> that has not been abandoned nor it's name relinquished. So please
> either disown the package or change its source to the original
> MoreWaita repo that I maintain, and do whatever you wish with the new
> forked repo. Till then, I'll keep insisting you stop hijacking the
> package name.
>
>
> On Sat, 21 Sept 2024, 15:15 Kainoa Kanter,
> <kainoakanter_at_gmail.com_fino@duck.com> wrote:
>> "inappropriate humor"? What in the world are you talking about?
>> Please stop harassing me over a project you abandoned.
>>
>>  Sep 21, 2024 5:54:48 AM fino@duck.com:
>>
>>  > It may well be facetious, although I don't see where I'm using
>> inappropriate humour regarding this.
>>  > You, on the other hand, didn't even think of sending me a message
>> before hijacking the package. Please disown it or change the repo
>> back to the original.
>>  >
>>  > On Fri, Sep 20 2024 at 23:26:59 -03:00:00, Kainoa Kanter
>> <kainoakanter_at_gmail.com_fino@duck.com> wrote:
>>  >> It's facetious to say that I "never replied to your message",
>> you sent it two hours ago.
>>  >> Sep 20, 2024 9:25:05 PM notify@aur.archlinux.org:
>>  >> somepaulo [1] filed an orphan request for morewaita-git [2]:
>>  >>> This package is for an icon theme that I'm developing on
>> github. A co-
>>  >>> developer, dusansimic, created the morewaita and morewaita-git
>>  >>> packages on AUR and was maintaining them, but at some point he
>>  >>> disowned the packages without telling me. I've only realised
>> this
>>  >>> today, when I got an unexpected update on the morewaita-git
>> package.
>>  >>> When this package got disowned, user That1Calculator adopted it
>> and
>>  >>> today he changed the source repo from my git original to a
>> recent fork
>>  >>> by somebody else, while keeping the same package name. I've
>> written to
>>  >>> That1Calculator asking him to disown the package on AUR, but
>> haven't
>>  >>> received a reply. Nor has he replied to my comment on the
>> package
>>  >>> page.
>>  >>> I've adopted the release-based morewaita AUR package, and I
>> would like
>>  >>> to adopt the morewaita-git package as well, being the original
>> author
>>  >>> of the MoreWaita icon theme. Thank you!
>>  >>> [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/somepaulo/
>>  >>> [2] https://aur.archlinux.org/pkgbase/morewaita-git/