[PRQ#54150] Deletion Request for shellcheck-bin
AlphaJack [1] filed a deletion request for shellcheck-bin [2]: Package is now available in official repos: https://archlinux.org/packages/extra/x86_64/shellcheck/ [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/AlphaJack/ [2] https://aur.archlinux.org/pkgbase/shellcheck-bin/
Hello. I don't see the point why I should have 218MB dependencies on my computer. And I'm not interested in haskel development at all. And the shellcheck package is almost twice as big. $ paru -S shellcheck resolving dependencies... looking for conflicting packages... :: shellcheck and shellcheck-bin are in conflict. Remove shellcheck-bin? [y/N] y Package (49) Old Version New Version Net Change Download Size extra/ghc-libs 9.0.2-3 138.41 MiB 19.03 MiB extra/haskell-aeson 2.1.2.1-37 10.38 MiB 1.33 MiB extra/haskell-assoc 1.0.2-246 0.07 MiB 0.02 MiB extra/haskell-attoparsec 0.14.4-70 2.63 MiB 0.39 MiB extra/haskell-base-compat 0.12.2-1 0.33 MiB 0.08 MiB extra/haskell-base-compat-batteries 0.12.2-75 0.33 MiB 0.08 MiB extra/haskell-base-orphans 0.8.8.2-6 0.34 MiB 0.07 MiB extra/haskell-bifunctors 5.6-57 3.10 MiB 0.43 MiB extra/haskell-comonad 5.0.8-241 0.63 MiB 0.11 MiB extra/haskell-contravariant 1.5.5-3 0.45 MiB 0.06 MiB extra/haskell-data-array-byte 0.1.0.1-47 0.13 MiB 0.03 MiB extra/haskell-data-fix 0.3.2-98 0.20 MiB 0.04 MiB extra/haskell-diff 0.4.1-71 0.33 MiB 0.07 MiB extra/haskell-distributive 0.6.2.1-205 0.27 MiB 0.04 MiB extra/haskell-dlist 1.0-235 0.26 MiB 0.06 MiB extra/haskell-erf 2.0.0.0-24 0.06 MiB 0.02 MiB extra/haskell-fgl 5.8.2.0-4 2.03 MiB 0.36 MiB extra/haskell-foldable1-classes-compat 0.1-57 0.57 MiB 0.08 MiB extra/haskell-generically 0.1.1-1 0.10 MiB 0.02 MiB extra/haskell-ghc-bignum-orphans 0.1.1-1 0.01 MiB 0.01 MiB extra/haskell-hashable 1.4.3.0-36 0.63 MiB 0.11 MiB extra/haskell-indexed-traversable 0.1.3-49 0.82 MiB 0.12 MiB extra/haskell-indexed-traversable-instances 0.1.1.2-34 0.09 MiB 0.02 MiB extra/haskell-integer-logarithms 1.0.3.1-6 0.11 MiB 0.03 MiB extra/haskell-onetuple 0.3.1-71 0.02 MiB 0.01 MiB extra/haskell-primitive 0.7.4.0-103 1.84 MiB 0.28 MiB extra/haskell-quickcheck 2.14.3-53 3.45 MiB 0.58 MiB extra/haskell-random 1.2.1.1-154 1.70 MiB 0.23 MiB extra/haskell-regex-base 0.94.0.2-2 0.39 MiB 0.07 MiB extra/haskell-regex-tdfa 1.3.2.2-34 3.25 MiB 0.55 MiB extra/haskell-scientific 0.3.7.0-109 0.56 MiB 0.12 MiB extra/haskell-semialign 1.2.0.1-150 0.81 MiB 0.14 MiB extra/haskell-semigroupoids 5.3.7-132 2.87 MiB 0.38 MiB extra/haskell-splitmix 0.1.0.5-14 0.18 MiB 0.04 MiB extra/haskell-statevar 1.2.2-2 0.09 MiB 0.02 MiB extra/haskell-strict 0.4.0.1-220 1.08 MiB 0.18 MiB extra/haskell-tagged 0.8.8-1 0.33 MiB 0.06 MiB extra/haskell-text-short 0.1.5-75 0.34 MiB 0.08 MiB extra/haskell-th-abstraction 0.4.5.0-1 1.01 MiB 0.17 MiB extra/haskell-these 1.1.1.1-247 0.61 MiB 0.10 MiB extra/haskell-time-compat 1.9.6.1-93 0.73 MiB 0.14 MiB extra/haskell-transformers-compat 0.7.2-1 0.83 MiB 0.12 MiB extra/haskell-unordered-containers 0.2.20-8 1.68 MiB 0.26 MiB extra/haskell-uuid-types 1.0.5.1-12 0.31 MiB 0.07 MiB extra/haskell-vector 0.13.1.0-21 9.49 MiB 1.17 MiB extra/haskell-vector-stream 0.1.0.1-1 0.52 MiB 0.08 MiB extra/haskell-witherable 0.4.2-91 0.94 MiB 0.14 MiB shellcheck-bin 0.9.0-1 -14.63 MiB extra/shellcheck 0.9.0-79 23.27 MiB 3.55 MiB Total Download Size: 31.17 MiB Total Installed Size: 218.57 MiB Net Upgrade Size: 203.94 MiB Best regards, Silvio
AlphaJack [1] filed a deletion request for shellcheck-bin [2]:
Package is now available in official repos: https://archlinux.org/packages/extra/x86_64/shellcheck/
[1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/AlphaJack/ [2] https://aur.archlinux.org/pkgbase/shellcheck-bin/
-- -- Silvio ------------------------------------------- silvio@port1024.net --
Just as a fellow user, I'd vote against deletion, and +1 for keeping this. I too prefer this package to be installed, because I also don't need its 47 haskell deps on my system, nor the weelky or even more frequent version bumps of repo's haskell-based packages. Btw, as per overwhelming AUR precedent, upstream-provided precompiled deliverables are allowed for open-source code, in the form of 'releasename-bin' packages. This one satisfies such conditions.
Request #54150 has been Rejected by gromit [1]: Same reject reason as the last time: - valid -bin package https://lists.archlinux.org/hyperkitty/list/aur- requests@lists.archlinux.org/message/JSML4GVKIMFT2KM7QPBFOY5AJZL7J3BV/ [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/gromit/
participants (3)
-
Marcell Meszaros
-
notify＠aur.archlinux.org
-
Silvio F.