[PRQ#51387] Orphan Request for ttf-literata
xiota [1] filed an orphan request for ttf-literata [2]: otf-literata and ttf-literata contain mutually incompatible replaces directives. Not only is the use of the replaces directive in opposition to the AUR submission guidelines, but in some use case scenarios, they cause problems for the user. These include third- party binary repositories, custom local repositories, and some aur helpers. Start by installing otf-literata. On upgrade, pacman will present the following messages. Users who do not accept will be presented with these messages every single time they try to upgrade their system. :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-opticals? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-webfonts? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-webfonts-opticals? [Y/n] Users who accept the replacement are presented with the following messages at the next upgrade. Similarly, if they do not accept, they will see these messages every time they try to upgrade their system. :: Replace ttf-literata with custom/otf-literata? [Y/n] :: Replace ttf-literata-opticals with custom/otf-literata? [Y/n] :: Replace ttf-literata-webfonts with custom/otf-literata? [Y/n] :: Replace ttf-literata-webfonts-opticals with custom/otf-literata? [Y/n] If they do accept, they are returned to the previous state and set of messages. :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-opticals? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-webfonts? [Y/n] :: Replace otf-literata with custom/ttf-literata-webfonts-opticals? [Y/n] Back and forth, ad infinitum, until they uninstall all literata fonts or uninstall the repositories or aur helpers. This is unacceptable user-hostile behavior for a set of font packages. Since the same maintainer owns both packages, and has explicitly refused to fix them, it may be inferred that this is intentional malicious behavior on the part of the maintainer. These packages should be orphaned to prevent this maintainer from harming users so that someone else can correct the issue. [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/xiota/ [2] https://aur.archlinux.org/pkgbase/ttf-literata/
On Thu, 16 Nov 2023 18:38:14 -0500 Pedro A. López-Valencia <palopezv@null.net> wrote:
To the AUR managers, as the maintainer, I consider this harassment. Thank you.
Consider it whatever you want (nobody cares), but the simple fact is that they're right, your use of replaces here is completely and totally wrong. Read up on what replaces means in a PKGBUILD before rejecting the suggesting, and read up on what harassment is as well.
Request #51387 has been Rejected by muflone [1]: invalid reason to orphan [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/muflone/
participants (3)
-
Doug Newgard
-
notify@aur.archlinux.org
-
Pedro A. López-Valencia