[PRQ#47521] Deletion Request for nvidia-pf
MarsSeed [1] filed a deletion request for nvidia-pf [2]: It is not useful to keep this badly and sporadically maintained package. I've explained the problems in a comment in 2023-06, as well as in emails to the maintainer. He was unwilling to address those, and he still does not even regularly update the version. Also he updates his linux-pf package a bit more frequently than this - which in many cases breaks this package. My comment from 2023-06-22, the day of the last update: " This new version is wrong. It just repackages the current, fixed version of repo nvidia-dkms for the linux-pf kernel that is currently installed. The package will prevent pacman sysupgrade the instant repo pushes a new version update to nvidia-utils (because of this [*a] versioned depends). / As of now, it also has a bogus "linux-pf>" entry. / The installed package will also break when there is a new linux-pf update without a new nvidia-pf update. It can also potentially break if there is a simultaneous new linux-pf update and nvidia-pf bump, if the user just builds linux-pf without immediately installing it, then builds nvidia-pf, then wants to install both. (The reason behind the latter two issues is this line of PKGBUILD [*b], which was designed by repo maintainers for a specific setup of build steps - building, then installing the intended kernel version before creating the nvidia module package. It does not make sense to just copy-paste repo's solution to this AUR pkg.) It's better to just rely on nvidia-dkms, which will do the correct thing every time there's a new linux-pf update and/or an nvidia-dkms update, and won't ever prevent sysupgrade. My recommendation still stands: delete this package, no one has used it for the last 4 years, and no one needs to. " [*a]: https://tinyurl.com/nvidiapfPKGBUILDline10 (full URL: https://aur.archlinux.org/cgit/aur.git/tree/PKGBUILD?h=nvidia- pf&id=41a9a1a8ff04697ba72292684aff010d3920336e#n10 ) [*b]: https://tinyurl.com/nvidiapfPKGBUILDline25 (full URL: https://aur.archlinux.org/cgit/aur.git/tree/PKGBUILD?h=nvidia- pf&id=41a9a1a8ff04697ba72292684aff010d3920336e#n25 ) [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/MarsSeed/ [2] https://aur.archlinux.org/pkgbase/nvidia-pf/
I don't get your crusade on this package. Yes I didn't update the package but there many, many other packages in the aur that have the issue or worse. I have a typo in the pkgbuild that I will fix. But so far all other issues you reported are simply not true or intended. E.g. the package depends on an explicit version on purpose.
Request #47521 has been Accepted by Antiz [1]: [Autogenerated] Accepted deletion for nvidia-pf. [1] https://aur.archlinux.org/account/Antiz/
participants (2)
-
Björn Bidar
-
notify@aur.archlinux.org