On Tue, Sep 03, 2013 at 04:02:07PM +1000, Allan McRae wrote:
On 21/08/13 11:57, Dave Reisner wrote:
On Mon, Aug 05, 2013 at 11:17:13AM +1000, Allan McRae wrote:
On 05/08/13 03:25, Dave Reisner wrote:
I've been using these patches for a while now (see the author date on the actual patches) and would like to present them again for feedback. I've found it tremendously useful (particularly as an Arch packager) to be able to keep an eye on other repos like [staging] without actually having them enabled.
I like these patches, and I believe I had the last version of them on my working branch for a while. I have just one comment for some discussion:
+*Usage =* ...:: + Set the usage level for this repository. This option takes a list of tokens + which must be at least one of the following: + *Sync*;; + Enables refreshes for this repository. + *Search*;; + Enables searching for this repository. + *Install*;; + Enables installation of packages from this repository during a '\--sync' + operation. + *Upgrade*;; + Allows this repository to be a valid source of packages when performing + a '\--sysupgrade'. + *All*;; + Enables all of the above features for the repository. This is the default + if not specified.
I think the description here needs to be clearer. Sync allows use to list the contents of the repo with -Sl?
Acting on a repo explicitly should ignore usage. I suppose I could make that clear.
Search, Install and Upgrade obviously imply Sync. Does Install only allow explicit installation - i.e. "-S repo/foo", or is "-S foo" enough?
If you set 'Install' for Usage, '-S foo' is sufficient.
Is Upgrade different from All? I would assume it implies Install (just by description).
-U has no concept of repos. Usage isn't relevant here.
So here is my suggestion. Can we put these in an order where the higher up ones imply everything below?
Sync < Search < Install < Upgrade == All
Allan
Hrmm. So, I suspect that 'Sync Search' will be the common alternative as 'Sync' or 'Search' on their own are not very useful, though 'Sync' alone will still allow for -S $repo/$pkg. 'Install' without 'Sync' *and* 'Search' isn't very useful either, but if you want the effects of all 3 of these, you simply don't specify usage.
I'm +0 on the idea of adding a hierarchy. Anyone else have an opinion?
On IRC we discussed not adding the hierarchy and adding some more documentation.
@Dave: are the patches on your branch good to go now?
Allan
Yeah, I rehashed some of the documentation to make it a bit clearler. What's on my branch should be good to go.