On Fri, Dec 16, 2011 at 12:15 AM, Rodrigo Amorim Bahiense
On 12/16/2011 02:03, Jeffrey Lynn Parke Jr. wrote:
I don't really think that people put any conscious thought into if they should top or bottom post. A majority of mail clients and the aforementioned Gmail default to top posting. What I would like to know is why is this the common practice. Obviously, people on forums and mailing lists like everything in the top down, first to last format. This frustrates me. I'll have to look into that greasemonkey plugin.. I am always fighting gmail on this issue.
I believe top posting is common because [average] people don't use e-mails to write/read long texts anymore, but rather for chatting.
Actually, nowadays it seems natural that if there is a way people can chat through some text message system, they will. I've unfollowed a lot of people who apparently thought twitter was just another web messenger.
this topic is a sinkhole, but what you've stated is an individual's failure to recognize social context, and adjust behavior accordingly. i mean, people don't act the same way with their own family vs. meeting their partners for the first time, do they? or their close personal friends vs. new business acquaintances? or when traveling abroad? or on a first date? or <insert almost any situation>? ... no, they don't. the internet allows for obscene levels of anonymity that simply *cannot* exist in traditional/direct communication -- permitting illusions of zero responsibility, fault, repercussion, embarrassment, or humiliation for their activities and escapades -- and is why trolls and all other forms of internet garbage exist. entering a community without competently researching and gratuitously accepting their established customs/preferences is completely asinine; entering that community and publicly smearing said customs, followed by proclamations of your own, is pompously asinine. it's not uncommon for me to spend hours on a reply/question, occasionally approaching 4hrs or more, and sometimes spread over several days, as i aim to be as clear, complete, and useful as possible to the greatest number of people, on *either* side. anyone who does not read to learn and write to teach is > /dev/null. -- C Anthony